Mandukya Upanishad, Class 50: Summary of Chapter 3

In Mandukya Upanishads, 7th mantra
is crucial and two significant words in that mantra are prabanjobasama and
advaidam.  The word prabanjobasama is
explained in the second chapter.  That means prabanja mithyatvam. 
This prabanja mithyatvam is explained by Gowdapadha with the word prbanjaj
vaithathyam.  In second chapter Gowdapadha explained the mithya of
prabanjam.  Prabanja can be described

  1. Prabanja equals to viswa, virad plus taijasa,
    hiranyagarba  plus pragya, eeswara all these six put together is
  2. Gross body and gross objects, subtle body and subtle
    objects, casual body and causal objects put together is prbanja
  3. Prabanja is the group consisting of pradhama padha,
    dwedia padha, tritaya padha or the first three padas put together. Padha
    thrayam equals to prabanja
  4. The first two padhas are kariyam or product; third
    padha is called karanam; prabanja the whole universe consisting of kariyam
    and karanam. Prabanja mithyatvam means kariyam is also mithya and karanam
    is also mithyam.

The third chapter is advaida
prakaranam and explains the word advaidam.  Advaidam is the name given to
the fourth pada, thuriyum.  Since the first three padas are in the form of
kariyam and karanam, the fourth pada should be kariya karana vilakshanam. 
the word advaidam refers to the thuriyuam which is neither kariyam nor
karanam.  That thuriyam is the atma, which is I myself.  The essence
of mandukya is I am the sathya thuriyum.  The kariya karana prabanja is
floating in me and whatever happens there will not affect me.

This chapter has 48 verses which can
be classified into five portions or topics:

  1. Introduction:  the first two verses;
  2. Dhrishti nisehtha or negation of the creation or kariya
    prabanja; also known as ajathi vajaha
  3. Atma gyanam or self-knowledge; two special words used
    are atma sathyanu bodhaha and asparsha yogaha
  4. Nidhithyasanam; internalization of vedantic teaching or
    assimilation of wisdom.  Mano nigraha; regulation of our thoughts in
    keeping with the vedantic teaching.  Re-orientation and
    reconciliation of our thinking and mind.
  5. Conclusion


All duality will cause samsara;
whether the duality is secular or sacred.  All forms of karma or actions
which involve duality are also samsara, even if those actions are religious and
ritualistic.  Karma is samsara whether it is lowkika or not.  All
forms of upasana involves duality even though they are in the form of
mediation of various deity.  They come in the form of duality of devotee
and deity.  All dwaidams are samsara because in dwaidam there is time and
space; wherever time is there yama dharma raja.  Time alone is responsible
for birth, growth, decay, decease, death, separation of near and dear
ones.  If dwaidam is samsara, advaidam alone gives moksha.

Both kariyam and karanam will come
under dwaidam.  All the products and cause will come under dwaidam because
in the kariya prabanja we experience duality.  Whether you take a tree, it
is full of duality with trunk, leaves, flowers etc.  Same with human
body.  Karnam is also dwaidam because it is nothing but kariyam in
unmanifest form.   Therefore, karanam is also dwaidam, but this
dwaidam is not visible therefore it appears like advaidam.  Like sushukthi
appears as advaidam, but it is also dwaidam.  Nirvikalpa samadhi is not
advaidam, dwaidam is there in potential form.  The real advaidam is beyond
kariyam and karanam.

Dhrishti nisehtha or negation of the

Brahman, the thuriyum, advaidam is
beyond kariya karanam and neither kariyam or karanam.  Gowdapadha focuses on the
part that thuriyum or brahman or atma is not karanam.

No product has come out of
thuriyum.  This means nothing is born out of Brahman.  This he does
in four stages:

  1. Logical negation of jiva shrishti:  Pot space is seemingly born, but on inquiry you find out that birth and death, movement, plurality – everything belongs to pot only.   Pot space does not have birth, death, movement or plurality.  Body alone has birth, death, movement.
  2. Logical negation of creation:  through dream example, he logically negates the creation  of the world.  In dream it appears as though a world is created, there is space, time, object, transactions.  Even though all these are seemingly born, but there is only one mind full of thoughts and there is no time, no object and no transaction.  On waking you know; this is really not there.  Similarly, from the standpoint of waker, there is time, object, space, transactions; but all of them are so tangible and real but when you wake up to thuriyum higher order of reality, this world is unreal.  Dream world is unreal, from the dreamer’s standpoint, it is real.  Similarly, this world is unreal but thuriyum standpoint, this world is unreal.
  3. Scriptural of negation of jiva shrishti:  Scriptures clearly reveal jivatma paramatma aikyam. Through maha vakyams.
  4. Scriptural negation of jagat shristy:  Scriptures repeatedly negate the universe by the statement there is no plurality at all in front of me.  If the universe is not born, how am I seeing.  If swapna prabanja is not born, how do you see it?  This is an erroneous perception.  It only appears to be born; it is maya or mithya from thuriyum standpoint.  From waker’s standpoint, the world is real.  For waker’s transactions, the world is required.  You can say world is unreally born.  This is mithyatavam.  Since there is no kariya prabanja, Brahman can’t be called karanam.  Brahman is kariya karana vilakshanam.

Atma gyanam or self-knowledge

Mind alone is responsible for
samsara by creating duality.  Moksha requires tackling the mind. 
Mind is the cause of samsara and amani bava is the solution; another word is
mano nasaha;

  1. Mano nasaha means destruction of ignorant, problematic, burdensome mind.  This you do it by making the mind wise.  Replace the problematic mind by non-problematic mind by getting wisdom.
  2. Mano nasaha is understanding the mind as mithya; once the mind is understood as mithya it is as good as destroyed because mithya mind is as good as nonexistence.

Snake can be understood only by understanding the
rope; mind can be understood as mithya by understanding thiriya
adhishtanam.  Atma gyanam as the only means of mani pava and the only
means of moksha.  This atma gyanam is given two names:

  1. Atma sathyana bodhaha:
  2. Asparsha yogaha:  A knowledge of myself which is free from all relationships.  Atma is relationless because relationship requires duality; advaidam is non duality; in advaida atma, there is no question of any relationship.

When you say atma gyanam is freedom
from all relationship, that can be frightening.  We think security is
because of relationship.  Advaidam will tell the real security  is
discovering security in myself not in spouse, father, mother or guru or
god.  As long as security comes from outside, you are in trouble.


internalization of vedantic teaching
or assimilation of wisdom.  Who is the candidate for nidhishytasanm:

  1. Manda Adhikari: 
    Limited qualifications has neither gyanam or gyana palam.
  2. Madhyamna Adhikari: 
    Medium sadhana sadhushta sambandhi;  he has sufficient
    qualification to receive the knowledge; but gyana palam does not come
    which means internal transformation does not take place.   Such people
    have to take to nidhidhyasanam or dwelling up on the teaching.  It
    can be in the form repeated hearing; writing; reading, discussing,
    teaching are all nidhithyasanam.  Formal method of nidhithyasanam is
    vedantic meditation which is ashtanga yoga.  Lord Krishna elaborates
    in the sixth chapter.  Gowdapadha also talks about this
  3. Uthama Adhikari: Maximum sadhana sadhusta sambandhi:
    Gets gyanam and gyana palam at the same time

Restlessness, dullness, tendency
experience occurring in meditation are the four obstacles; remove the obstacles
and practice nidhithyasanam  Design the type of meditation that is
suitable to you; gyanam will be converted to gyana nishta and the teaching will
be available during transactions.


This thuirya atma alone is the
highest reality or paramarthika sathyam; everything else experienced by me
either pradhipadhika sathyam or vyavakarika sathyam and are mithya.  In I
the thuriyuam mithya prabanja appears and disappear;


Fourfold Qualifications